Space← All Shows Like
Shows Like Supernatural
Looking for shows like Supernatural? Here are 10 series with the same monster-of-the-week brotherly drama.
FantasyDrama2005
Best Shows Like Supernatural
The best shows like Supernatural are The X-Files, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and Grimm. Each blends supernatural horror with serialized drama.
Looking for shows like Supernatural? Here are 10 series with the same monster-of-the-week brotherly drama. We picked each title based on shared tone, themes, and emotional feel.
1. The X-Files
1993Sci-FiWhy it's similar: Two FBI agents investigate paranormal cases. The original monster-of-the-week format that inspired Supernatural.Vibe: dark, supernatural, proceduralWhere to watch The X-Files
2. Buffy the Vampire Slayer
1997DramaWhy it's similar: A chosen girl hunts vampires while navigating high school and beyond. The godmother of modern supernatural drama.Vibe: supernatural, dramatic, actionWhere to watch Buffy the Vampire Slayer
3. Grimm
2011FantasyWhy it's similar: A detective discovers he is descended from hunters who fight supernatural creatures. Near-identical premise.Vibe: supernatural, proceduralWhere to watch Grimm
4. Lucifer
2016FantasyWhy it's similar: The Devil moves to LA and helps solve crimes. Same celestial mythology and brooding lead.Vibe: supernatural, funnyWhere to watch Lucifer
5. Good Omens
2019FantasyWhy it's similar: An angel and a demon team up to prevent the apocalypse. Same heaven-vs-hell mythology.Vibe: supernatural, funnyWhere to watch Good Omens
6. The Vampire Diaries
2009DramaWhy it's similar: Two vampire brothers vie for the same girl in a Virginia town. Same CW supernatural drama energy.Vibe: supernatural, romanticWhere to watch The Vampire Diaries
7. Charmed
1998FantasyWhy it's similar: Three sisters discover they are witches and must fight demons. Same sibling bond hunting supernatural evil.Vibe: supernatural, dramaWhere to watch Charmed8. Angel
1999FantasyWhy it's similar: Angel moves to LA and fights demons while running a detective agency. Direct Buffy spinoff, dark and excellent.Vibe: dark, supernaturalWhere to watch Angel
9. Sleepy Hollow
2013FantasyWhy it's similar: Ichabod Crane is resurrected to fight the Headless Horseman. Same mythology-driven supernatural procedural.Vibe: supernatural, adventureWhere to watch Sleepy Hollow
10. Stranger Things
2016Sci-FiWhy it's similar: Kids in the 80s fight supernatural threats from another dimension. Same government-conspiracy mythology.Vibe: supernatural, nostalgicWhere to watch Stranger Things
Why These Shows Are Similar to Supernatural
Every title connects to Supernatural through shared Fantasy&Drama DNA — tone, themes, and the emotional feel that makes Supernatural memorable.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the closest show to Supernatural?
The X-Files (1993). Two FBI agents investigate paranormal cases. The original monster-of-the-week format that inspired Supernatural.
What should I watch after Supernatural?
Start with The X-Files, then try Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997).
Are there more Fantasy shows like Supernatural?
Yes — all 10 picks share the dark, supernatural, adventure tone.
What are the top 3 shows like Supernatural?
The X-Files, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and Grimm.
Hidden gem similar to Supernatural?
Stranger Things (2016) — Kids in the 80s fight supernatural threats from another dimension. Same government-conspiracy mythology.